104,000 views to this website.

Website has been getting views daily mostly from Ireland but with an increasing number of International visitors. Not many new posts have been made over past view months because we have been viewing documents that were previously not made available to us. We will not comment on what we have found until this process is completed which will be in the coming weeks.

No recorded/detected murders in Leix/Offaly per 1985 commissioner report

 

No recorded/detected murders in Leix/Offaly per 1985 commissioner report

 

A follower on Twitter @smackovsky brought this to my attention today.

REPORT ON CRIME 1985

Report for the year ended ,1985.

Commissioner, Garda Siochána, to the Minister for Justice.

p1040226

p1040227

 

 

Finally a response on behalf of the Minister ( after 14 months )

Friday afternoon this is an email My cousin Henry and myself were sent from the Department of Justice. We had a meeting with the Minister last year and she promised to get back to us after the summer break. We heard nothing and both of us wrote to the Minister and got not reply. On the 8th of August a letter was sent to the  Ombudsman complaining about the Minister’s non response to our meeting and letters. As a result of which the following was received by email. Interesting to see if hard copies will follow

 

 

Minister’s Reference: 0718095057

26  August, 2016

Dear Mr. McCourt,

I  have  been  asked by the Tánaiste and Minister for Justice and Equality,
Ms.  Frances Fitzgerald T.D., to refer to her meeting with you and Mr. Bill
Maher  on 1 July 2015, the matters outlined in the documents which you gave
to her at the meeting and in your subsequent correspondence.

In  the  first instance, I should say that it is a matter of regret that it
did  not  prove  possible  to  issue  a definitive response until now.   Of
course,  the  papers  submitted  by  you  had  to  be fully reviewed by the
Tánaiste  since  originally  submitted and she wanted to take the time that
was  necessary to fully consider all of the matters raised in light of your
strong  concerns.   Moreover,  you  will  appreciate  that  in the interim,
events, relating to other pressing matters, placed very significant demands
on the Tánaiste’s time.

The  Tánaiste  would  like,  once  again,  to  acknowledge the very sincere
support  which many people have conveyed to you and your family in relation
to the death of your uncle, Fr. Molloy, and the extent of the efforts which
have  been  made over many years to obtain answers to the various questions
which have been raised about the case.

The  Tánaiste has reflected on the issues discussed with you at the meeting
and  as referred to in the documentation supplied and sympathises with you.
However,  the  detailed  examination by the SCRT of the case, together with
Mr.  McGinn’s  subsequent  report,  lead  her  to conclude that there is no
reasonable  prospect  that  a  further  inquiry  would  give  rise  to more
conclusive  results.   The  objective  expressed  in  Mr. McGinn’s terms of
reference  was to obtain definitive independent advice on the question of a
further inquiry and having received such advice, it would be highly unusual
for the Tánaiste not to take it on board.

The  Tánaiste  has also considered your comments on the shortcomings of the
original  Garda  investigation but as you note in your documentation, these
have  been  highlighted  by  the  SCRT  and  were  outlined  and  carefully
considered  by Mr. McGinn in arriving at his recommendations concerning any
further  inquiry. While the Tánaiste fully appreciates your dissatisfaction
with these aspects of the original investigation, she does not believe that
a  further  inquiry  to  examine  these specific matters would be viable or
warranted  at  this  remove.  As  stated  in  previous  correspondence, the
Tánaiste  is of the view that a further inquiry would most likely come to a
similar assessment in relation to the original Garda investigation and such
an  assessment  is  already  available  and in the public domain.  In these
circumstances,  and  given  the  passage  of  time  and  the  evolution  of
investigatory  practice  since then, the establishment of a further inquiry
into these matters would not be of material public benefit.

The  Tánaiste  is  very much aware that unanswered questions in relation to
the  case  remain and are of course a cause of concern for the family.  She
sympathises  with your desire to see further steps taken in relation to the
investigation  but, as you know, the case has been considered by the DPP on
foot  of  the  SCRT  report  and  a  direction received that there not be a
further  prosecution.   The  Tánaiste  has  no role in that process, but by
publishing  Mr.  McGinn’s report has taken exceptional measures to put into
the public domain as much information as possible in relation to a criminal
investigation,  and  in  relation  to the steps taken to examine the issues
which have been raised concerning the case over many years.

Having carefully considered the points which you raised at the meeting, and
in  your correspondence, the Tánaiste remains of the view that there are no
further avenues open to her in relation to this matter, and that she is not
in a position to accede to your request to establish a further inquiry into
the case.

Yours sincerely,

Niall Colgan
Private Secretary to the
Tánaiste and Minister for Justice and Equality

CC Mr. Bill Maher 

Frances Fitzgerald ignores family of Fr Niall Molloy

We met with Minister for Justice Frances Fitzgerald in July 2015. We spent an hour talking to her and left her with a file and  photographs which she herself described as ” distressing”. She promised us she would respond after the Summer break..

In November 2015 she informed Denis Naughten T. D. that she would be in touch with family members.

Nine months on from our meeting and we have heard NOTHING from her.

Fr Niall Molloy bloodstains. ( What Bloodstains ? )

 

 

 

Bloodstains. Fr Niall Molloy

(Photograph shows bloodstains clearly visible on the carpet beside the body of Fr Niall Molloy)

 

Under cross examination at the Inquest Dr. Dan O’Sullivan was asked –

192. And you saw a fair amount of signs of blood around the bedroom ?

I didn’t notice any blood around the bedroom.

193. You didn’t notice any blood around the bedroom ?

No

 

 

Fr Deignan said in his statement that he noticed “bloodstains on the carpet nearby”

Sgt. Ford Said in his statement ” I lifted the towel and saw that there was blood on the dead man’s face, I also noticed that his upper lip burst and there was a cut on the lower left jaw “

Sgt. Forde went on to describe blood stains he had noticed in other areas of the room.

 

Dr. Harbison also mentioned  “blood staining on the floor, over a distance of 8ft.to 9 ft”

Bloodstains and marks were also detailed by Gardai who did a forensic examination of the scene.

 

And Dr. O’Sullivan saw no bloodstains. ?????????

Richard Flynn was questioned at the Inquest

457. Mr. Flynn did you clean the wounds on Fr. Molloy’s face ?                         – No

458. When you went to whisper an act of contrition in his ear did you notice his face ?

– No

458. can I ask you how it is you came not to notice his face at the time ?

-Because his head was turned over on his right side and I whispered an act of contrition into his left ear.

460. Why didn’t you turn him over ?

– Because his ear, his left ear was nearest to me and I whispered an act of contrition into his left ear.

 

I have seen the Garda photographs of the room and of Niall’s body. It is quite obvious from those photographs that there was a considerable amount of blood present. It is also obvious that someone attempted a clean up.

We gave copies of the photographs to Minister for Justice, Frances Fitzgerald last July, She has not reponded despite promising to do so after the Summer break in 2015

Update : August 2016. Still no response from Frances Fitzgerald.

Written question from Denis Naughten T.D.

QUESTION NO:  329
DÁIL QUESTION addressed to the Minister for Justice and Equality (Deputy Frances Fitzgerald)
by Deputy Denis Naughten
for WRITTEN on Tuesday, 10th November, 2015.  

 
 *  To ask the Minister for Justice and Equality further to her meeting with the family of a person (details supplied) in July 2015, if she will report on the progress to date on the issues raised at that meeting; and if she will make a statement on the matter.

– Denis NaughtenFr Niall Molloy  
REPLY.

As the Deputy will be aware, I agreed to reflect on the issues which the family in question raised at the meeting referred to, and I can advise him that I expect to contact the persons concerned directly in the near future.